11. Security Considerations
The focus of this document is security; hence security considerations permeate this specification.
IPsec imposes stringent constraints on bypass of IP header data in both directions, across the IPsec barrier, especially when tunnel mode SAs are employed. Some constraints are absolute, while others are subject to local administrative controls, often on a per-SA basis. For outbound traffic, these constraints are designed to limit covert channel bandwidth. For inbound traffic, the constraints are designed to prevent an adversary who has the ability to tamper with one data stream (on the unprotected side of the IPsec barrier) from adversely affecting other data streams (on the protected side of the barrier). The discussion in Section 5 dealing with processing DSCP values for tunnel mode SAs illustrates this concern.
If an IPsec implementation is configured to pass ICMP error messages over SAs based on the ICMP header values, without checking the header information from the ICMP message payload, serious vulnerabilities may arise. Consider a scenario in which several sites (A, B, and C) are connected to one another via ESP-protected tunnels: A-B, A-C, and B-C. Also assume that the traffic selectors for each tunnel specify ANY for protocol and port fields and IP source/destination address ranges that encompass the address range for the systems behind the security gateways serving each site. This would allow a host at site B to send an ICMP Destination Unreachable message to any host at site A, that declares all hosts on the net at site C to be unreachable. This is a very efficient DoS attack that could have been prevented if the ICMP error messages were subjected to the checks that IPsec provides, if the SPD is suitably configured, as described in Section 6.2.
Related Sections: